This article contains Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Buying through our links does not change the price you pay.
I do most of the cooking and baking in our family: macarons, cakes, pies, and everything for the holidays. Our KitchenAid stand mixer does most of that work. Every November, friends ask me the same thing: “Do I really need one, or will a hand mixer do?” The honest answer depends on what you bake, not on how serious a baker you are.
One note before we start: the stand mixer in this guide is the kind I use at home. I haven’t owned the two hand mixers below; my picks for those are based on their listings, warranty terms and what owners say in Amazon’s review summaries.
Quick picks
250 W peak, QuickBurst, bowl rest, whisk and a snap-on storage case.
Check price on AmazonLight, quiet, stainless turbo beaters, lockable swivel cord.
Check price on AmazonShopping on Black Friday (November 27)? Stand mixers are classic deal items. Add the one you want to your cart now so you can check it quickly when deals start.
Holiday jobs, task by task
| Job | Hand mixer | Stand mixer | My tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whipped cream | Great | Great | Chill the bowl; stop at soft peaks for pie |
| Mashed potatoes | Great | Good, paddle | Low speed, short time, or they turn gluey |
| Pumpkin pie filling | Great | Fine | A whisk works too; don’t whip in air |
| Boxed or simple cake batter | Good | Great | Scrape the bowl twice |
| Cookie dough, big batch | Struggles | Great | Stiff dough is where hand mixers overheat |
| Meringue, pavlova, macarons | Tiring | Great | Long whipping is easy hands-free |
| Dinner rolls, bread dough | No | Great, dough hook | Or knead by hand |
| Pie crust | Not ideal | OK, paddle | A pastry cutter or your fingers work best |
Which mixer do you need?
Mixer picker
What a hand mixer does well
A hand mixer is fast to grab, fast to wash and lives in a drawer. For short jobs, whipping a cup of cream, beating eggs and sugar, mashing potatoes in the pot they cooked in, it’s often quicker than setting up a stand mixer. You can also use it in any bowl or pot, which matters on Thanksgiving when every bowl is in use.
Where hand mixers give up is heavy, long work. Stiff cookie dough makes the motor strain, and whipping egg whites to stiff peaks for a big pavlova means standing there for many minutes holding it.
What only a stand mixer does well
The big advantage is your hands. When I make macarons, the stand mixer whips the meringue while I weigh the almond flour and sugar. When I make rolls, the dough hook kneads while I peel potatoes. That’s worth more on a holiday than any speed setting. I wrote up my speeds and timing in how I make macarons in our KitchenAid.
The downsides are real too: it’s heavy, it takes counter space, and it costs many times more than a hand mixer. If it will live in a cupboard and come out twice a year, buy the hand mixer.
What owners complain about
Owners love the quality, colors and quiet motor and say it’s easier than a big stand mixer for simple jobs. The split is on power: some say it struggles with cake batter and mashed potatoes.
Read reviewsOwners praise the power, value and the case that keeps beaters together. Complaints: the first speed not working properly for some, and units breaking after about a year.
Read reviewsOwners love the performance and how easy cakes and pasta become. Complaints: paint chipping on white attachments and some units that stopped working.
Read reviewsThinking about a KitchenAid? Our KitchenAid Artisan review goes deeper into the model, its attachments and its weak spots.
The mixers in detail
Hamilton Beach 6-Speed Electric Hand Mixer
A 250-watt peak motor with six speeds and a QuickBurst button, two beaters and a whisk, all dishwasher safe, and a snap-on case that keeps them together. The bowl rest lets it sit on the edge of the bowl so drips stay inside.
Pros: most power for the money; whisk included; storage case; bowl rest.
Cons: louder and bulkier than the KitchenAid; some units fail after a year.
KitchenAid 5-Speed Ultra Power Hand Mixer KHM512
Five speeds, from stirring in chocolate chips to whipping meringue, two stainless turbo beaters that go in the dishwasher, a one-hand eject button and a cord that locks to either side. It comes in many colors.
Pros: quiet; light; comfortable; lots of colors.
Cons: no whisk in the box; some owners want more power for thick batters.
KitchenAid Artisan 5-Qt Tilt-Head Stand Mixer
The classic: metal construction, a 5-quart stainless bowl, 10 speeds and a tilt head for easy access to the bowl. Our stand mixer at home is a KitchenAid, and it’s what I use for macarons, cakes and holiday doughs. The attachment hub takes pasta rollers, grinders and more.
Pros: hands-free; handles heavy doughs; huge attachment range; lasts for years with care.
Cons: heavy; takes counter space; expensive; some paint chipping on white attachments.
Comparing KitchenAid models? See KitchenAid Artisan vs Classic. Cooking the turkey too? Our meat thermometer guide takes the guessing out of it.
FAQ
Is a hand mixer good enough for Thanksgiving?
For most Thanksgiving jobs, yes: whipped cream, mashed potatoes, pumpkin pie filling and boxed or simple cake batters are all easy with a hand mixer. It struggles with bread and roll dough and with long whipping jobs like meringue for a crowd.
Can you make mashed potatoes with a hand mixer?
Yes, on low speed and only until smooth. Mixing too long, with any mixer, makes potatoes gluey, so stop as soon as the lumps are gone.
Do I need a stand mixer for bread dough?
For regular kneading, a stand mixer with a dough hook saves a lot of effort. Most hand mixers aren’t made for stiff yeast dough; you can knead by hand instead.
Is a KitchenAid stand mixer worth it?
If you bake often, especially meringues, macarons, bread, big batches of cookies or layer cakes, yes: it works hands-free and handles heavy doughs. If you bake a few times a year, a hand mixer does most of the work for a fraction of the price and space.
What speed should I whip cream at?
Start on low to avoid splashing, then go to medium-high until soft or stiff peaks form. Chilled cream and a chilled bowl whip faster.
Sources
- KitchenAid 5-Speed Ultra Power hand mixer KHM512 (Amazon listing)
- Hamilton Beach 6-speed hand mixer with QuickBurst and bowl rest (Amazon listing)
- KitchenAid Artisan 5-quart tilt-head stand mixer KSM150PS (Amazon listing)
Affiliate disclosure: Smart Home Shields is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. If you buy through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Product details on Amazon change often, so check the current listing before you buy.